« Garrett didn't want to give up play-calling in 2011, but willing to let Callahan's role 'evolve' | Main | What got Callahan to Dallas? Jerry Jones, the stadium, the reputation of the franchise »

January 22, 2012

Steve Young says Romo as good as Brees, Brady at elite plays but struggles with 'game manager' part of QB's job

NFL analyst Steve Young says Tony Romo is as good as any quarterback when it comes to the highest level of quarterback play, but that he struggles with another important part of the job – game management.

Young, speaking on a conference call last week to promote ESPN’s coverage of the NFL’s conference championship games, was talking about Alex Smith’s reputation in previous seasons as a “game manager.”

 “The problem I have with the idea of game manager, it's definitely code for: ‘He can't play championship football.’ It's like calling someone a scrambler. That's code for: ‘He isn't a real quarterback,’ Young said. “The truth is, scrambling is a side light to it. It doesn't really have to define you. And game manager, that's 60 or 70 percent of the job. To my mind, Tony Romo, the 30 percent that's the extra-highest level, point-of-the-spear championship play that Drew and Tom and all those guys do, Tony does really well. But he struggles with more of the commodity, the game manager stuff.”

Romo is coming off what his coach, Jason Garrett, called his best season yet, with a career-best 102.5 passer rating, 31 touchdowns and 10 interceptions.

Romo's critics won't let him forget the second-half turnovers he had against the Jets and the Lions that snatched defeat from the jaws of victory.

But ESPN analyst Trent Dilfer doesn’t blame Romo. He blames the team around him.

“Tony has greatness in him,” he said. “I think when you talk to other people that really play the quarterback position, and I see it as well, there's a few guys that really have incredible greatness in them, and Tony is one of them. I think the issue here is he needs more help from his teammates. I think they are not nearly as talented as people say they are, from 1 to 53. I'm talking about the total roster. I don't think there's as much order and structure in the organization as the Giants have and the teams that have the elite quarterbacks have. I think the only thing that's keeping Tony from ascending into the upper echelon of quarterbacks is his team, is the help from his friends and his teammates, and I think once that all comes together, you're going to see the fullness of Tony's greatness come out."

-- Carlos Mendez

Twitter @calexmendez



TrackBack URL for this entry:

Listed below are links to weblogs that reference Steve Young says Romo as good as Brees, Brady at elite plays but struggles with 'game manager' part of QB's job:


I agree with your idea.You look like very talented.It is very happy to meet you. Thank you!

Hey Carlos...can you send this article over to the guys at DMN.COM? Seems they will not print ANYTHING disparaging on either Romo OR Garrett...lol. Steve Young had a 'coachspeak' moment...He said one thing and he said what he meant...Way to go Young!! Romo IS NOT a championship quarterback. Trade him to Cleveland and a few picka for the fourth pick of the draft.. Then select RGIII. We'd be in the Super Bowl in two, three years..

"Champions aren't made in gyms. Champions are made from something they have deep inside them - a desire, a dream, a vision. They have to have the skill and the will. But the will must be stronger than the skill"

This is something that Romo will never have. He doesn't have the heart that it takes to be a champion.

The comments to this entry are closed.