If you were Stu...

We all love Stu Barnes, and his tough-as-nails play has made him one of the most respected players for the Stars, as well as in the league.

But now Barnes is at a crossroads in his career: Play another year (or so), or retire. Barnes had a bad concussion at the end of last season, one that cost him the last several games of the playoffs. Every time he tried to come back, he had another relapse. We all know if you suffer enough of those, the repercussions could be quite damaging. Now if he's sufficiently recovered, he could certainly still play. On the other end, there's a chance that he could join the Stars staff, possibly as a coach. Obviously his knowledge would be invaluable to this group, and he certainly would fit right in given his relationship with fellow Stars.

So in the spirit of the intermission quiz featuring the center last season, I switch one word in its title and ask you this: What should Stu do?

Comments

[dwain]

Retire from active play and be a Stars coach. He's a good guy I love his style of play, but for his family I would rather him retire and not risk the damage another concussion could bring. His style of play makes more hits likely.

I really hate to see him retire, but...

[Lucas]

sign a 10 year deal, win 4 cups and a playoff MVP and beat Chelios for oldest player in this new NHL era.

[Scotty Hockey]

Stu has been one of my favourite players for years so it would be really sad to see him hang 'em up but if the concussion was that bad that he is risking his future well-being by going out there again, then it's been grand ... He had a really solid career as a NHLer and should make for a good coach. Best wishes ...